Quantcast
Channel: Rewriting Russian Gymnastics
Viewing all 863 articles
Browse latest View live

Online and TV coverage of European Gymnastics Championships

$
0
0

Collage of the Russian Junior team by Lifje.  Clockwise from top left: Seda Tutkhalyan, Anastasia Dmitrieva, Daria Skrypnik, Maria Bondareva, Angelina Melnikova

Official podium training for the juniors begins today at 10 am and runs right through till 7.30.  I haven't heard of any quick hits but will let you know as soon as I do - or please share information in comments.

In the UK, the BBC has finally confirmed its schedule of coverage, which isn't bad if you have red button.  See below.  I have already posted information and links to online and TV coverage elsewhere in Europe - please follow this link.  
http://www.rewritingrussiangymnastics.blogspot.co.uk/#!http://rewritingrussiangymnastics.blogspot.com/2014/05/how-can-i-follow-european-gymnastics.html

Gymnastics on the BBC

Saturday, 17th May

Women's European Gymnastics, Women's Team Final, 12:50 BBC Red Button

Women's European Gymnastics, Women's Team Final, 17:45 BBC Red Button

Sunday, 18th May

European Championships: Women's Apparatus Final, 11:50 selected Connected TVs

European Championships, 14:30-16:30 BBC Two

European Championships, Women's Apparatus, 16:30 BBC Red Button


I hope you get to see as much of the gymnastics as you desire!


Good luck to Seda, Angelina, Maria B, Daria Sk, Anastasia, Daria Sp, Anna, Alla, Maria K and Aliya!  We are all thinking of you.






Another year of Rewriting Russian Gymnastics

$
0
0

At my university we have finally made it to the time of year when we can concentrate on writing and research.  It is a clear change of pace; from the relentless chitter chatter and interaction of teaching and assessment to a shorter, sometimes more reflective, time.  It is over all too quickly, and though I love my time with the students, increasingly I would rather be reading and writing.  It is very important to plan my work so I don't waste the coming couple of months when we have just a little more breathing space.

When I began my blog I first of all saw it as a channel for my writing, secondly as a route to self-understanding: what on earth is it about gymnastics, Russian gymnastics in particular, that I find so compelling?  After three and a half years of blogging (769 posts!) and 2.6 million page views ... Well, I am a little wiser, but no less hooked to my subject.  In fact, if anything, I have dug myself deeper and deeper into a multi-layered world.  There are not enough hours in the day, weeks in the year, years in a lifetime for me to cover this subject in sufficient depth.  I want to thank all the journalists, bloggers, translators, photographers, marketers and fans who are forever contributing to my personal picture of Russia, its gymnasts and its wider context of sport, friendship and international relations.  This ever-changing picture, sometimes flickering and indistinct, often clear and beautiful, occasionally sad and painful, is what gives me the stimulus to keep on writing. 

I have also slowly begun to realise that it isn't just gymnastics that fascinates me.  Without Russia, gymnastics would be meaningless to me.  Russia is simply intoxicating.  The wholly different philosophy of sport.  The pretty colours in the amazingly ornate architecture.  The way the language looks and sounds. The people.  The woody smell - is it fennel, is it sandalwood?  Gymnastics and Russia is a perfect match of mystery, culture, sport and politics ... gymnastics is a window into a world that I will never really know, but can't stop exploring.

My self-knowledge still has a long way to go.  I know now, for example, that being read means far more to me than the tortuous process of writing!  Comments and discussions are very often the most interesting part of this blog.  I don't write as much as I would like; often I am merely reporting events, or providing summaries of what is being said in the Russian press.  One thing I had not envisaged when beginning the blog is that a whole community of interested people would build up around it; 3076 followers on Facebook is far more than I ever expected.  But of course, this makes for a responsibility towards the blog's followers; I try to provide an overview of all the main things, but can't do everything.  Other blogs, such as the excellent Videos of Russian Gymnasts, are better at keeping track of the up and coming juniors, the Russian Gymnastics Federation site is increasingly useful for its links to news stories and brief profiles of team members.  The gymnastics groups in VK.com keep us up to date with the gymnasts' lives as far as is respectful to them as people, and the various Tumblr blogs give some useful insights.

I say I don't write as much as I would like to, but it is vital to chronicle the events of Russian gymnastics and to collate the central events in its developments if I am to be able to write anything meaningful about the sport.  This blog therefore tries to be a repository for the key sources.  Some of the most under-used resources here are the tabs to the right of the blog's home screen, where links to articles, a bibliography and a list of video documentaries can be found.  There is also an archive of all the past posts on the blog, accessible by date.  You can search by label to find all the articles on a particular subject.

So I am now looking forward to another year of blogging and learning about Russia, its artistic gymnastics and its sports system.  I am going to write another post imminently - in the next few days - talking about the different areas of knowledge that I could develop here.  I want to try to add depth to my work more than breadth, so expect a few surprises.  

If you have read this far, and have thoughts and ideas on the direction this blog is taking and could take in future, please leave your ideas in a comment or two - I love reading them and they are always useful.

Maria Kharenkova at the European Championships

$
0
0

'Veteran' junior, now first year senior, Maria is participating in her first major senior competition this week.  There are some fabulous pictures on the RGF website of her, her team mates and the coaches.

Words are one thing.  Much has been said about the participation of Mustafina, the prospects of Russia's young team in competition against the experienced Romanians, and those absent through injury.  It's clear that in medal terms, there is little pressure on this team to perform.

The pictures speak of another reality.  The tense expectations of Russia's elite have been replaced by the optimistic efforts of a new generation.  The coaches are seen to be encouraging, supporting and involved.  The team appears to be working happily.  Three members of the senior team - Mustafina, Kharenkova and Sosnitskaya - have their personal coaches here with them.  The roster of personal coaches travelling to a competition is often a measure of which gymnasts are expected to do the best.  In Sosnitskaya's case, her coach Maria Ulyankina is also responsible for junior Seda Tutkhalyan.

I have chosen to feature Maria here as she promises much as the emerging star of this Russian team.  But all the gymnasts have something special about them - the mischievous twinkle of Rodionova, Spiridinova looking happy and confident; pretty, hardworking Sosnitskaya.  Mustafina, as ever, is mesmerising.   There are lovely pictures of all the team members - pay a visit to the RGF site if you want to see them all (www.sportgymrus.ru).  I will post highlights on RRG's Facebook page also, later today.

The junior team and qualifying competition begins today.  Good luck to all the participants!




Maria with head coaches Grebyonkin and Rodionenko


With her personal coach from her hometown of Rostov on Don, Olga Sagina








Ksenia Afanasyeva - Sports Express interview

$
0
0

Photo credit : Tatiana Dorogutina, Sports Express

This is a summary (not a comprehensive word by word translation) of an interview with top Russian gymnast, Ksenia Afanasyeva.  The original Russian language interview is available at http://summer.sport-express.ru/gymnastics/reviews/44509/

Olympic silver medalist, twice world champion Ksenia Afanasyeva told "SE" why she decided not to finish her gymnastics career after the London Olympics.

Ksenia Afanasyeva was going to retire from gymnastics after the Olympics in London. These Olympics were the second of her career, and she was much more successful there than at the Beijing Games of 2008.  Having come home empty handed from Beijing, she instead won a team silver in London.  Then, contrary to expectations, she stayed in the sport. Last year, she performed at the European Championships and Universiade, but after that she suffered some health problems. Now she is in Germany, rehabilitating after a third surgery on her ankle.

'The first operation took place last year, right after the Universiade, the second was in December. The third was almost two weeks ago. The problem is the same - a torn ligament. The doctor's first thoughts were not to do anything too complex, but after two such operations I still couldn't tumble.  So, after the Russian championships, I turned to Valentina and asked her to send me to Germany for consultation.  My doctor frankly admitted that he does not specialise in the operation that I still needed, and redirected me to another clinic.'

'You could not ask for the "complex" operation right away?'

'To be honest, how could I know?  I agreed with what the doctor suggested.  At the time of the second operation I asked whether it would be difficult to do the operation right, but the doctor said he would recommend this operation to his own daughter.'

'How was the third operation?'

'It has gone well.  At this clinic there is a very good rehab center where many famous sportsmen have been treated.  Dr. Buhorn, who did my third operation, specializes just on the ankle and works primarily with athletes.'

'How long will the recovery period be?'

'The timing is much less serious than the other operations.  Before this, it had been about eight months.  Dr. Buhorn has said that in three months I'll be able to tumble.  But he said he did not yet know about the inflammation of the bone.  For a very long time I was tumbling with an injured foot, so they found during the operation that the bone had become inflamed.  So now we are doing lymphatic drainage and physiotherapy.'

'You are going to return to sport after recovery?'

'After the first two operations, I really thought a lot about it. Now, to be honest, I mostly want to feel like a complete human being, who isn't upset by the constant pain in her leg. Although of course it has already been two years since I was injured, and during that time I have managed to get used to the pain.'

'What happened two years ago?'

'During the Russian Championships, just before the Olympics, I performed in the final floor exercise, doing two whips to a triple twist. I landed badly from the triple twist and from this moment started having problems with my foot.  I finished the exercise; probably because of the adrenaline I did not feel particularly acute pain.'

'How did you compete with such an injury at the Olympics?'

'Now I also ask myself this question! I still do not know.  I remember that there was pain, and about a month before the Olympics we talked with the coach.  We decided then that if I could not do floor, I would do beam.  Then I did shock-wave therapy, which dulled the pain. There were no other options. But I was able to tumble again - through pain, but the pain was bearable.'

'Why didn't you talk more about the seriousness of the injury?'

'I do not see much sense in talking about problems. I did not want to make excuses for a failure because of my injury.  Also, I doubt that my performance would be better if people knew I had a sore foot.  But to my coach I certainly complained.  Her ears must have buzzed!  But I understand that each person has their own problems, why should anyone worry about mine?  When I could tumble, I tumbled.  When I realized I could no longer do it, I spoke about it.'

'Before the Olympics, you said that this could be the last start of your professional career. Why, then, are you still in the sport?'

'First of all, I didn't want to return, but then the coaches discussed and persuaded me.  I thought it over ... And I decided to stay.'

'Do you regret it?'

'No. Of course, during rehab I will probably curse all professional sports, but I understand that sport is my life, and I still want to leave on a good note.'

'A silver medal at the Olympic Games wasn't a sufficiently good note?'

'Of course, it was a success! But it is not an individual medal.'

'How hard was it to return to training after London?'

'It was very hard.  I constantly had thoughts about the meaninglessness of these workouts.  I remember that the all-around qualification at the European Championships left me frustrated. And then I had a real hysteria. After the competition, I was crying, my mum and coaches calmed me as well as they could.  It was a tragedy: I ​​was preparing very seriously, I had diligently improved my unloved bars routine.  Perhaps, if I had not won gold on the floor, I would have left the gym.'

'Your mother was also involved in gymnastics?'

'Yes, she is a master of sports and now teaches gymnastics at the institute.  By the way, my mother was originally categorically opposed to me becoming a gymnast. She wanted me to study and just to be a normal girl. But they came to us in kindergarten to recruit. The coach, who led the selection, persuaded my mother.  At every stage, she and my grandmother gave me the choice of leaving the sport.  But after London, my mum kept quiet and said I needed to decide for myself whether to stop.  She is very worried about my health.  I showed her my leg and we discussed whether I could continue.  I am a woman, I want to have children, not end up in a wheelchair.  But if I feel strong enough to run and tumble, then of course I will continue to train.'

'Where do you see yourself after your athletic career?'

Ksenia replies that she is considering training as a psychologist or as a vet.  She is not sure about psychology - not sure she is ready to take on other people's problems.  On the other hand, the difficulty of being a vet is that animals cannot say what is wrong.  She loves animals and tells a story of how she rescued a stray dog, and eventually found its owners so it could go back home.  She feels sorry when she walks past the pet shop and sees animals in 'rotten little cells'.

'You do not see yourself in sports?'

'I can't say that I'm a very big sports fan.  I never wanted to be a coach because I don't want to spend my life in the gym. On the other hand, studies cost money ... in general, if I could finish my career with dignity, finish Veterinary Academy, and then open a clinic, I would probably be the happiest person on earth.'

Russia wins junior team title, leads all around

$
0
0
Young Russia.  Back row from left to right - national junior coach Bulgakova, ?, national junior coach Voinov, Andrei Rodionenko, ?.  Front row - Maria Bondareva, Angelina Melnikova, Seda Tutkhalyan, Daria Skrypnik, Anastasis Dmitrieva

Congratulations to the ambitious young Russians who today won the Junior European team championships in a tight competition, but eventually by a fairly substantial margin.  Britain is the up and coming nation in European WAG, dominating on vault and floor with powerful work, but stalwarts Romania put up a strong fight for bronze, only a very small margin behind.  Their top gymnast, Jurca, will be looking to prove herself in the remaining individual competitions.






Melnikova and Tutkhalyan lead Friday's all around qualifying


On vault, Tutkhalyan is an impressively powerful gymnast who could compete with Downie, Jurca and Tinkler for gold. In fact, vault will be a very close competition with less than .5 separating the top five in qualifications.  Melnikova performs a DTY but is less powerful than the top qualifiers.


Russia scored first on bars in team, and it shows in these event qualifying results.  Melnikova manages to combine the highest E score with the second D score at this competition.


Melnikova will compete in three event finals on Sunday.  Tutkhalyan, with a fall, is less than a point behind the leader.  Russia leads on beam with the top difficulty scores on the day.


Another impressively tight final on floor with the Romanians looking very powerful and confident by all reports.  Britain's Catherine Lyons has the highest E score here while Jurca takes the top D score.  Tutkhalyan and Dmitrieva have qualified to this final, meaning that only Bondareva will not compete in any final, as things stand.  


MALADYETS, Russia!  Angelina, Seda, Maria, Daria, Anastasia, keep fighting!  

Tomorrow, look forward to the senior team qualifications.  At present, Russia's working order stands as follows : 

V. Kharenkova, Rodionova, Sosnitskaya
UB. Spiridinova, Rodionova, Mustafina
BB. Spiridinova, Mustafina, Kharenkova
FX. Spiridinova, Kharenkova, Sosnitskaya

Some lovely pictures have shown up on the girls' Instagram accounts.  Seda looks so proud here - http://instagram.com/p/n_OKTvwMol/.  All the girls look happy - http://instagram.com/p/n_OEdCwMod/.


Make sport not war

$
0
0
Russian gymnasts and coaches at the European Gymnastics Championships in Sofia, Bulgaria, sit shoulder to shoulder with their Ukrainian friends, including 1985 World Champion Oksana Omelianchik.

Picture courtesy of the Russian Gymnastics Federation


All good luck to all competitors in the senior final.  Udachi!

Peace and friendship to all.

Personality

$
0
0
The Russians have it, in buckets; the gymnasts on this junior team are no different.  In my opinion, this is one of the most talented junior teams the Russians have produced in recent years; I only hope that at least two of them can navigate the choppy waters to senior status, and go on to compete at the very highest level.  Good luck to them all!

This is the eighth consecutive year that the Russian junior team has won at Europeans.

Pictures courtesy of the RGF

Anastasia Dmitrieva

Seda Tutkhalyan with coach Ulyankina

Seda Tutkhalyan 

Angelina Melnikova


Seda T, Maria Bondareva and Angelina ... What ON EARTH are they discussing?  Captions please ...

Determination - Seda during her vault run up

Coach Ulyankina reassuring young Maria

Another intriguing discussion between Maria and Seda

Shared laughter ...

Daria Skrypnik with local gymnastics hero and rings specialist, Bulgarian Jordan Jovchev












Leaps of faith

$
0
0
I love to see a leap performed boldly and with finesse.  The flying type of leap that defies gravity.  Toe point and line come into it, but amplitude is what a leap is really all about; every muscle stretched to its optimum, grace balanced with energy and power, an invisible process of weightlessness propelled not only by the legs but also by the abdomen and, it sometimes seems, the sheer spirit of the gymnast. Ballet understands the forces of gravity and how strength is converted to elegance; a leap is not a bounce, something we all too often see in today's power gymnastics.  A leap hovers mid air.  Landing seems implausible. The gymnast is flighty, airborne.

A leap seems simple but is actually incredibly complex, drawing on countless hours of practice and body preparation.  Its execution is a matter of huge skill and courage.   Only the best can make such leaps of faith with artistry.  Coming down to land on the narrow beam, the gymnast often launches herself once more into inconceivable flight.  

Compare the pictures below to those of some legends of the sport : Mostepanova, Ilienko.  You won't be disappointed.  Bondareva, and especially Melnikova, are true to the Russian classical tradition.  Mustafina and Tutkhalyan embrace a more athletic genre; Tutkhalyan is a new style of gymnast for the Russians, at once strong and balletic; I see echoes of Mukhamedov as she explodes off the beam; in Mustafina's dynamic, supple and almighty work are shadows of the great Tourischeva.  In more ways than one.

Maria Bondareva, classic lines, but she was beam spotting at the moment this shot was taken 


Angelina Melnikova's trajectory in this leap gives an impression of flight, power and speed


Daria Skrypnik



The powerful Seda Tutkhalyan

Maria Kharenkova

My favourite leap from Mustafina - power, agility, classical line and amplitude.  A photographers dream.


Ludmilla Tourischeva - amplitude, in the Russian tradition














Russia 3rd in brave qualification round

$
0
0
Russia's young guns held their ground and performed mostly well today to secure a third place spot in Saturday's team final, and gymnasts in every event final on Sunday.  Ahead of them were an inspired British team who had their best competition today, and a strong but occasionally faltering Romanian team, led by the impressive Larissa Iordache who won the 'unofficial all around' with a near faultless display.  Switzerland's Giulia Steingrueber repeated her good performance at last year's Euros to come in second.  As this is a team and event Championships, Russia did not field an all around gymnast.

Highlights for the Russian team were bars and beam, with scores in the 15s from Mustafina (bars) and Kharenkova (beam).  Kharenkova's almost faultless beam set was delivered under pressure in the anchor spot, and came after a brave exercise from World Champion Mustafina, who completed her first double back dismount off the apparatus for the first time in weeks.  Emotions ran high in this part of South East London; could this be considered to be Mustafina's Comaneci 1979 moment?  Russia will begin on bars and finish on vault in the final.  Will Mustafina risk her all on a DTY for the sake of a team medal?  If so I think the tears will flow, hopefully for the right reasons.

I am not expecting Russia to win gold on Saturday, but the team gelled, and did some good work.  If they repeat this performance on Saturday, a medal should be the reward.  Sosnitskaya delivered reliable floor and vaults and Spiridonova and Rodionova made their mark on bars.  Kharenkova has staked her claim as a leading gymnast on the team, and hopefully she'll continue in the same vein for the rest of the week and year.  The few small errors - notably Spiridonova on floor and a wobbly beam from Mustafina - were to be expected and may well be put right in the final.  Overall, though, the team worked together well and show some significant promise for the future.  

We should also congratulate both the British and Romanian teams, who were clearly in the lead today!  

Good luck once again, keep up the good work!


Pictures courtesy of the organisers' Facebook page

















Angelina Melnikova Junior European Champion

$
0
0
Angelina Melnikova, courtesy RGF

It was a dominant performance by a strong and graceful young gymnast.  Congratulations, Angelina!

Seda had a few errors but will have gained experience here.  She still has a chance to win a medal on Sunday in one of her event finals.

Good luck to both gymnasts as the competition progresses.


The incomparable Piibunina is posting videos as I type this - 
http://m.youtube.com/user/piibunina/videos

Thoughts

$
0
0
Unless you have been hiding under a rock somewhere, you can't have failed to notice that Romania are now European Team Champions, with Britain in second place and Russia in third.  Congratulations to everyone!  These were well deserved medals.

I personally think that winning the bronze was a great achievement for this inexperienced team.  Aliya Mustafina proved that, even at 50%, she is 100% boss.  Kharenkova established herself as a real little scrapper who is now a leader in the team and even in world gymnastics.  Even with the unpredictable Komova I doubt Russia would have done much better today; it comes down not so much to the errors that were made, as to the low difficulty rating of those floor exercises.  The team needs its Olympians for good floor scores, but they just aren't available at present, nor perhaps in the future if I am reading Afanasyeva's rather damning account of the handling of her injury correctly.

I wonder if there will be any fall-out or consequences after this result?  No blame should lay at the gymnasts' feet, they gave their all; only Anna Rodionova perhaps let the team down somewhat, but since when did a Russian team go error free in a team final? Spiridonova is forgiven her beam error as she did so well elsewhere in her first big assignment.  Sosnitskaya, Mustafina and Kharenkova couldn't have done much more, and I think Mustafina and Kharenkova will both be going all out for gold in tomorrow's event finals.

I hope that tomorrow's press will not be full of Valentina making recriminations about this result.  The girls deserve some recognition for the difficult time through which they have mostly prevailed.  But the Russians are the Russians and faces say more than words.  A lot of thought lies ahead for many of those shown in these pictures.


Head coach Rodionenko - will there be fall-out or consequences?

Tumbling and vault coach, Vasily Ivanov



Coach to Afanasyeva, Marina Nazarova (presumably here in a team coaching capacity)

Head coach Evgeny Grebyonkin in an apparently rather glum exchange with Anna Rodionova


A quiet moment

Coach Olga Sagina's protégée Maria Kharenkova is carving a spot for herself as a leader


Even in disappointment Aliya finds the time for a photograph

What do you mean  ... ?

Pictures courtesy of RGF


Full BBC coverage of the event can be found at 












We are satisfied - Aliya Mustafina

$
0
0
Photo credit: RGF

An Allsport interview today with Aliya Mustafina : http://www.allsportinfo.ru/index.php?id=83075

'I think that we are to be congratulated on this bronze medal, we are more satisfied than frustrated', said Aliya Mustafina.

'We were a new team, all the girls are young, and it's their first time in such a serious competition.  I think today we performed to the best of their ability.  Yes, we have had two falls today - on the uneven bars and balance beam.'

'The young girls failed psychologically, but the first time you compete on the senior podium - it's not very easy.  No one is sad.  I am very pleased with such a performance.  Everything was fair enough, maybe not everywhere and in all things, but overall it was quite as expected, both our rivals, and the judging.'

'I began to experience more pain in the ankle - continued Aliya Mustafina. - To do the dismounts I had to muster all my strength and clench my teeth.  The coaches have decided that after the European Championships next week I will go to Germany for a check up, to see exactly what is happening with my ankle.  In Moscow before Europeans the ankle was checked and nothing too serious was found.'


Skrypnik, Melnikova take gold in Junior European Event Finals

$
0
0

Bars gold medallist Daria Skrypnik in Tuesday's qualification competition

Russia continued their dominance of Europe's junior championships today by making a 1, 2 on uneven bars (Skrypnik, Melnikova) and a first place on beam (Melnikova).  Britain took the remaining two medals in the power pieces of vault and floor. 

Tiny Seda Tutkhalyan (1999 born) gave her all here but was unlucky enough to have errors and miss out on medals.  Her full twisting back somersault on beam is excellent and throughout the competition she showed real spirit, good technique and good difficulty.  Hopefully she will get a chance to show her real mettle at the Youth Olympics later this year.  Anastasia Dmitrieva performed nicely enough on floor, but just didn't have the big skills necessary to medal at this level under this Code.

Melnikova and Skrypnik, both 2000 born, will just be old enough to be eligible for Rio assuming they transition to senior level safely and well.  Melnikova, who has a look of Zamolodchikova about her, trains in the same Voronezh gym as Viktoria Komova and Yulia Inshina.  She will therefore be well known to head junior coach Olga Bulgakova, who worked in Voronezh before coming to Round Lake.  Apparently a willowy type, Melnikova's body is deceptively strong and powerful, and she seems to have a tiger's eye during competition.  Hopefully that will continue.  Skrypnik, who looks about 6 feet tall but in fact is miniature compared to the British girls, is a magnificent bars worker of great skill and talent.  She comes from Krasnodar.

Vault result http://www.longinestiming.com/File/Download?id=00000D0000010002FFFFFFFFFFFFFF10

Bars result. http://www.longinestiming.com/File/Download?id=00000D0000010002FFFFFFFFFFFFFF20

Beam result. http://www.longinestiming.com/File/Download?id=00000D0000010002FFFFFFFFFFFFFF30

Floor result. http://www.longinestiming.com/File/Download?id=00000D0000010002FFFFFFFFFFFFFF40

There have been two interviews with Valentina Rodionenko about the Russian teams and I am so unhappy with their content I want to remind people what Alexandrov said about her :

' ... Any coach who does not repeat what she says and kiss her behind becomes an enemy.  Valentina is used to being the boss, and likes flattery very much. She completely destroys her enemies.'

Valentina says that 14 year old Tutkhalyan is a disappointment, calls out Rodionova and Spiridonova for their mistakes, acknowledges that the British did well but criticises them for their lack of aesthetic on grounds of their size.  She criticises the judging and fails to praise Mustafina to the skies for her determined and dedicated contribution to world gymnastics.

There are reasons behind what Valentina says about the judging and the aesthetic of the sport and they could be argued, but the manner in which they are said makes them indefensible and, therefore, counter productive.  I would never describe a gymnast as a 'disappointment' when what they do every day is so difficult and I just hope that this experience helps all the girls to develop an extremely thick skin.  

Perhaps the words come across in Russian more softly than they do in this admittedly short summary, that leaves out some of the more positive things she said - about Britain's improvement, for example.

'Valentina has not actually coached a day in her life'.

Mustafina is a better spokesperson for the Russian team and I hope she will be head coach one day.  Coaching is in her blood, it shows.





Kharenkova takes gold on final day of Euros

$
0
0


15 year old Maria Kharenkova saved the day for Russia with a well deserved gold medal on the beam this afternoon in Sofia.  To the visible delight of team mate and captain Aliya Mustafina, who has supported Kharenkova right through this competition, Kharenkova went through her difficulty packed routine with very little error, converting her junior gold from two years ago into her first major senior title.

Kharenkova is the latest generation of a long tradition of great gymnasts from the town of Rostov on Don in the south of Russia.  Her coach, Olga Sagina, formerly counted Anastasia Sidorova and Elena Produnova amongst her gymnasts.  Sagina's philosophy is pretty simple - champions must have discipline, and work hard. 'Head and intellect are very important', she said during a coaching clinic in Glasgow in 2008.  Kharenkova's earnest attitude and fighting performances speak much of this approach.  In team finals her positive attitude and determination kept her on the beam after a landing that was clearly offline.  Today she came out ready to do her best; her efforts reaped gold, and a big smile from a very serious girl. Maria will no doubt now return to Lake Krugloye determined to train even better for Worlds.  I wish her the best of luck.

Her team mate Mustafina didn't manage to win a gold medal this time, but looked thoroughly comfortable in her role as team captain.  Silver on bars and bronze on beam were a credit to her raw talent and the careful training of personal coach and beam specialist Raisa Ganina.  Limping heavily after the beam performance, Mustafina was not doing her full difficulty anywhere, but what she did do was to perform as close to perfection as her body would allow.  If anything, this was Mustafina's greatest performance, drawing on all her physical, mental and emotional energies to pull the Russian girls back from the brink of an empty handed Europeans.  I trust that the trip to Germany will resolve Aliya's ankle pain thoroughly, without any pressure to come back to full training and competition too quickly. She has shown here what a fantastic motivator she can be and her presence on the Olympic team in Rio will be vital to the team's morale. 

Dasha Spiridonova performed her bars routine beautifully for a bronze medal behind Britain's Beckie Downie (congratulations to an extremely emotional champion!) and team mate Mustafina.  Alla Sosnitskaya did her best in both her finals, floor and vault, but unfortunately these are Russia's weakest apparatus and she was unable to make much of an impression despite a strong effort.  The power and energy of Larissa Iordache and Vanessa Ferrari held sway this year.

As gymnastics moves on, it is evident that Russia needs to re-evaluate its training regimes to promote better performance on floor and vault.  I don't believe Valentina Rodionenko's idea that the Russians lack power (compared to the Americans, Germans and British) because they are relatively small; like boxing, power to weight ratio is what counts and the Russians have always been able to produce small but strong gymnasts in the past, eg Zamolodchikova, Lobazniuk, and not forgetting Komova and Grishina.  

Poor attention to detail is also slipping gradually into Russia's floor and vault work; eg compare Pavlova's leg form to Sosnitskaya's.  Both trained under the same system, yet the older gymnast has better basics there.  The only conclusion to draw is that something is slipping away from Russia's training and discipline that was once there so could presumably be restored fairly easily.  The only dependency here is that the coaches are supported in doing their jobs well.  But how much authority and control do they really have?  I am remembering now yet another part of Alexandrov's story; that his training plans were regularly altered by Valentina Rodionenko, who has never coached a single day in her life. That she deleted lines relating to specific conditioning and replaced them with a walk in the park.  I certainly hope that she is not misusing her influence all over again with coach Grebyonkin, who looked rather worried this week.

It is all too easy to seek to lay blame on one or two people and I don't want to malign Valentina - but so many of the things she says are silly and betray a lack of understanding, while the remaining coaching staff and gymnasts are thoroughly professional.  Besides the dipping competition performances, the evidence base is growing; for example, I am surprised that there hasn't been more fuss surrounding Afanasyeva's very measured, but somewhat damning interview.  A top gymnast who Valentina transparently propelled and promoted as an all around prospect, was persuaded to increase her difficulty on vault and bars, her weak pieces, despite a serious injury that sounds to be career threatening.

While Alexandrov's account pulled no punches, Afanasyeva's was quiet and factual.  Afanasyeva may need to return to a national team led by the Rodionenkos so was treading carefully.  Alexandrov had nothing left to lose.  They both ask similar questions about how Russia's WAG team is training.


Find all the scores from Sofia here http://www.longinestiming.com/Competition?id=00000D0000FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF&sport=GA&year=2014.

Link to Afanasyeva interview http://rewritingrussiangymnastics.blogspot.co.uk/2014/05/ksenia-afanasyeva-sports-express.html?showComment=1400428961531



Quotes of the day

$
0
0
The medal winners : Maria Kharenkova, Daria Spiridonova and Aliya Mustafina with team doctor Timonkin and head coach Grebyonkin (yes, it rhymes)


Aliya Mustafina (RUS), silver medallist beam:

"I am extremely happy that Maria Kharenkova took the gold on beam. The competition was not easy for me because of my leg injury, but I tried to pull myself together because I know my younger teammates are watching me and I shouldn`t show any weakness”.

 

Maria Kharenkova (RUS), gold medallist on beam:

"To tell you the truth I am too excited to tell you what is happening right now. As for Aliya she is our sister, our world star, our coach and even our mother, she is all for us. We are all very happy”.

 

Andrei Rodionenko (RUS), Head of delegation:

"As I already stated this European Championships gave us the best possibility to test our new team. Right now we have many problems with injuries with our more experienced gymnasts. They stayed at home while we had to test the youngsters. We are satisfied with the results during the Championships”.

 



Aliya Mustafina - I competed as best I could

$
0
0
Picture credit RGF

Aliya speaks in Sports Express
http://news.sport-express.ru/2014-05-18/699607

I am very pleased with my performance today, I don't know what the judges didn't like about my bars, but I didn't ask them ... I did my routine fairly well without serious error.

On beam I didn't have the start value but I received the highest execution score.  We will try to fix that before the World Championships.

Considering the problems I had with my ankle, I think I performed to the optimum at the moment.  I did everything I could.

I'm not the least bit sorry that I performed here - Very glad that I could help the team. I think my presence made things easier for the girls.  It is very difficult to compete at such serious senior competitions for the first time.  Of course they were very worried.  But I'm sure that with time they will learn to cope easily with their nerves (smiles). 

Maria Kharenkova - I had expected silver

$
0
0
Happy smiling face of Maria Kharenkova, courtesy RGF

Maria talks to Allsport

I am very pleased.  However, I had expected silver, because I thought that I would not beat the Romanian Larisa Iordache.

But I was able to do a good routine and surpass her.  Beam is my best apparatus (smiles).
... I enjoyed it. This was the first time I had performed at a major competition, so it was not very easy.  The rivals are very strong and have lots of difficulty.  For this reason we were nervous, and didn't perform very confidently in the team championship. 

[She suggests that she made too many errors]

The first priority, I think, will be to improve my start value on bars.  On beam my SV is good, I just need to work on cleanliness and correct errors that occur to be more confident.  On the floor, too, must be added more acrobatics, I will learn new elements and improve my start value.


http://www.allsportinfo.ru/index.php?id=83118

Tutkhalyan, Bondareva will fight to compete at Youth Olympics

$
0
0
Olga Bulgakova, courtesy of RGF

Key points of a short interview with Olga Bulgakova, Head Coach of the national junior team

http://www.allsportinfo.ru/index.php?id=83100

They had expected a little better result on floor and vault.  They need to review and change their tactics, work on the mistakes.  Bars and beam were the most successful pieces.

The girls reached their minimum targets.  They use the results of competition for analysis, to understand where things aren't working, and correct any weaknesses.

Seda Tutkhalyan and Maria Bondareva will be considered for the Youth Olympics in Nanjing.  Seda's programme is more complex.  But this was a major competition for both girls and both had errors.  There is still some work to do.

Seda has complex routines, dealing with them is very hard.  If her routines had been less difficult of course that would have been easier to handle and she would be more stable.  But that wouldn't offer much promise.  She has a very promising programme, they will make modifications.

Psychologically, these girls are a little short of international competition.  Now they will know better what to expect.  Our programmes are strong, but they shouldn't stand still.  They want still more information to analyse and make decisions.  The results may be different elsewhere.

Control competitions will be used to decide who will travel to Nanjing.

The gymnastics events at the Youth Olympics will take place between 17th and 23rd August.

In another interview, Bulgakova talks of the potential of the juniors 'they could well go to the Olympics in Rio'

http://summer.sport-express.ru/gymnastics/reviews/44640/

Seda only missed out in a podium finish because of mistakes, not because of her level or talent.  In fact she had the highest SV of everyone and to cope with this was far more difficult.  Now they have to do a bit more work until she begins to cope better.  There are real possibilities that these girls could go on to upgrade their routines even more and then qualify for the Olympics.

It is a bit early to say how these juniors will cope with the stress, they are still children.  But what these children did in Sofia, really deserves special praise.

Seda is the only gymnast in this competition to perform certain skills on the beam (I think she is referring to her full twisting back in the straight position).  I believe that with just a little bit more work, she will cope with everything.

Angelina Melnikova is a very hardworking and willing girl.  They told both her and Seda that whoever did not fall, would come first.  The fact that Angelina made no mistakes is very valuable.

Daria Skrypnik has very promising bars, but she had problems in qualifications.  Maria Bondareva and Anastasis Dmitrieva are good all arounders, but still young.

Seda and Angelina are a little taller than the other girls.  Their vaults are better than some of the seniors, but the new members of the senior team are facing puberty, which makes them prone to injury.  With time, they will improve their vaults.

She was quite surprised by the British success, but there is a British gymnastics tradition, the gymnasts can look up to Elizabeth Tweddle as an example.


RRG - Community standards and participation guidelines

$
0
0
The Russian Junior team enjoy some fresh air in Sofia after a hard competition.  Clockwise, from top left : Olga Bulgakova (head coach), Aleksandra Buzdalina (masseuse), Artem Voinov (team coach), Seda Tutkhalyan, Daria Skrypnik, Anastasia Dmitrieva, Maria Bondareva, Angelina Melnikova.  Courtesy : RGF


I like comments and discussions, and most of them on this blog are well informed, polite and interesting.  Please do keep posting!

However, in past days, some of the comments on this blog have been downright rude, to the extent of attacking the person, rather than arguing the point.   Passionate debate and strong opinions are encouraged, but not name calling, bullying or aimless contradiction of the last post.  I have deleted the worst ones, using a 'light touch' for now.  I will, however, have to consider further action if individuals persist in behaving so immaturely. 

It is time to establish some rules of participation; The best ones I have found are at the website of British newspaper The Guardian.  Let's try to adhere to them here.  Please take time to read them, and do please add to them in the comments if you have any thoughts :-)

There are some more articles to come out of Russia and I expect some of you will find them controversial.  I will be posting by the end of the week.

The following section (in italics) comes from http://www.theguardian.com/community-standards

The most important things are:

In short:

- If you act with maturity and consideration for other users, you should have no problems. 
Don't be unpleasant. Demonstrate and share the intelligence, wisdom and humour we know you possess.
Take some responsibility for the quality of the conversations in which you're participating. Help make this an intelligent place for discussion and it will be.


The Guardian Guidelines:

There are 10 simple guidelines which we expect all participants in the community areas of the Guardian website to abide by, all of which directly inform our approach to community moderation (detailed below). These apply across the site, while moderation decisions are also informed by the context in which comments are made.

1. We welcome debate and dissent, but personal attacks (on authors, other users or any individual), persistent trolling and mindless abuse will not be tolerated. The key to maintaining the Guardian website as an inviting space is to focus on intelligent discussion of topics.

2. We acknowledge criticism of the articles we publish, but will not allow persistent misrepresentation of the Guardian and our journalists to be published on our website. For the sake of robust debate, we will distinguish between constructive, focused argument and smear tactics.

3. We understand that people often feel strongly about issues debated on the site, but we will consider removing any content that others might find extremely offensive or threatening. Please respect other people's views and beliefs and consider your impact on others when making your contribution.

4. We reserve the right to redirect or curtail conversations which descend into flame-wars based on ingrained partisanship or generalisations. We don't want to stop people discussing topics they are enthusiastic about, but we do ask users to find ways of sharing their views that do not feel divisive, threatening or toxic to others.

5. We will not tolerate racism, sexism, homophobia or other forms of hate-speech, or contributions that could be interpreted as such. We recognise the difference between criticising a particular government, organisation, community or belief and attacking people on the basis of their race, religion, sex, gender, sexual orientation, disability or age.

6. We will remove any content that may put us in legal jeopardy, such as potentially libellous or defamatory postings, or material posted in potential breach of copyright.

7. We will remove any posts that are obviously commercial or otherwise spam-like. Our aim is that this site should provide a space for people to interact with our content and each other, and we actively discourage commercial entities passing themselves off as individuals, in order to post advertising material or links. This may also apply to people or organisations who frequently post propaganda or external links without adding substantively to the quality of the discussion on the Guardian website.

8. Keep it relevant. We know that some conversations can be wide-ranging, but if you post something which is unrelated to the original topic ("off-topic") then it may be removed, in order to keep the thread on track. This also applies to queries or comments about moderation, which should not be posted as comments.

9. Be aware that you may be misunderstood, so try to be clear about what you are saying, and expect that people may understand your contribution differently than you intended. Remember that text isn't always a great medium for conversation: tone of voice (sarcasm, humour and so on) doesn't always come across when using words on a screen. You can help to keep the Guardian community areas open to all viewpoints by maintaining a reasonable tone, even in unreasonable circumstances.

10. The platform is ours, but the conversation belongs to everybody.We want this to be a welcoming space for intelligent discussion, and we expect participants to help us achieve this by notifying us of potential problems and helping each other to keep conversations inviting and appropriate. If you spot something problematic in community interaction areas, please report it. When we all take responsibility for maintaining an appropriate and constructive environment, the debate itself is improved and everyone benefits.







Aliya Mustafina: 'Masha is very determined'

$
0
0
From Aliya Mustafina on Instagram: 'thanks for the invitation' she says to Alexei Nemov

A brief interview with Sovietski Sport is summarised here.  Original interview is at http://www.sovsport.ru/news/text-item/712772

Olympic gymnastics champion Aliya Mustafina today went to a party organised by famous gymnast Alexei Nemov, entitled "Sochi-Moscow-Rio".  Alexei handed out some awards, sponsored by the magazine 'Grand Sport'.  It took place in the Veshny Arts Centre.

- Aliya, soon you are going to Germany for a check up on your ankle. How do you feel now?

- Walking does not hurt, it only hurts when I tumble.  I really would like the doctors to figure out what is going on with my foot, and why I cannot load it. And how to treat it  ...

- As I understand it the European Championships did not disappoint you in any way, despite the fact that you lost to Downie on the bars?

- No, no disappointment.  I did not show a routine of the highest difficulty, and just performed as well as I could.  I did OK, and didn't fall anywhere, so I see no reason to get upset. For the World Championships on bars, I will try to prepare a programme to compete at a World level.

- As far as I know, the coaches discouraged you from traveling to Sofia, but you still decided to go. With injury.

- I myself wanted to perform, I'm not used to missing out if I can compete at all.  Besides, I knew it was important to help the young girls, who were on the podium for the first time.

- Maria Kharenkova became European champion on the balance beam, beating Iordache.  Nobody expected it, including Masha herself.

- Well, why would no one have expected it?  For example, I knew that Masha has a strong programme, a good "start value".  If she does everything clean, she may well fight Iordache. Masha is still a little girl, she just came onto the team, she's only fifteen years old, but she is very determined.  I think she has a good future. Her bars are a little weak, but it will be possible to improve.





Viewing all 863 articles
Browse latest View live